The nature and nurture debate disputes the extent to which behavior is a product of inherited or acquired influences. This controversy has been scrutinized for several decades but has not reached unanimity due to various factors and ceaseless arguments. The main argument for the nature side is that genetics significantly influence behavior, with environmental factors during adolescence having minimal effect. This is supported by "Twin studies," which emphasize nature's role and have led to further extensive research. However, both factions need equivalent support for prospective studies to achieve a balanced understanding.

Genetic similarity, the more significant genetic similarities between two individuals, is divided into Monozygotic (identical) and Dizygotic (fraternal) twins. Monozygotic twins share 100% genotype, while Dizygotic twins share 50%. Bouchard and Lykken conducted the Minnesota twin studies to emphasize nature's influence, measuring characteristics of Monozygotic twins reared apart (MZA) and together (MZT). The results showed that MZA and MZT shared similar characteristics, demonstrating genes as a dominant influence on personality traits.

Despite this, criticisms challenge the dominance of nature. Critics argue that the researchers did not fully publish their data, making independent assessment difficult. Additionally, the characteristics analyzed-such as blood pressure, intelligence, WAIS IQ, and brain wave activity-are already known to be influenced by genetics. These findings, while significant, fail to examine personality and other subjective, unmeasurable traits directly.

Personality and character formation, often regarded as significantly impacted by nurture, were not thoroughly analyzed in the twin studies. This raises questions about whether nature is genuinely the dominant factor in shaping individuals. Indeed, while the genome undeniably plays a colossal role, nurtural factors may contribute more to shaping individuals, particularly in aspects beyond measurable traits like brain and body activities.

신시은 강남포스트 학생기자  webmaster@ignnews.kr

<저작권자 © 강남포스트, 무단 전재 및 재배포 금지>